Season 1 (2013):
Frilly Filly Farm (Aksanka93 Resident, Lilitha Triellis)
Season 2 (2013):
Frilly Filly Farm 1 (Aksanka93 Resident, Clairesoclever Resident, Lilitha Triellis, Xsennon Resident
Season 3 (May 2014):
1st Division: Stones n Rubber 1 (Ariel Erlanger, Devious Lei, Seras Resident
2nd Division: Fabulous Pony Ranch (Arthurine Sommerset, Ayesha Askham, Blitz Firethorn, Fakoz Kohime)
Season 4 (September 2014)
Darkwing Alikat (Jo Ronin, Katinka Taerdrop, Safra Nitely, Taya Maruti)
Season 5 (May 2015)
1st Division: Silenced (Jenni Silverpath, Parquala Resident)
2nd Division: Stones n Rubber 2 (TPELatexgirl Resident, Vision Nikita)
Season 6 (March 2016)
1st Division: Wildfire Stables 1 (Seldon Juliesse, Taka Salome)
2nd Division: Wildfire Stables 2 (Alli Eberdene, Hephestuscolt Resident, Wetjody Resident)
Season 7 (July 2017)
1st Division: Royal Horses 1 (Alli Eberdene, Hephestuscolt Resident, Taka Salome)
2nd Division: Royal Horses 2 (Carissabellane Resident, Geneveive Bellflower, Juliabennett Resident)
Season 8 – Classic Polo League Season 1 (April 2018)
Tearfall AE (Bambikins Resident, Pigwitchhouse Resident, Seras Resident)
Season 9 – Classic Polo League Season 2 (March 2019)
Upper Playoffs: Tearfall (Bambikins Resident, Pigwitchhouse Resident)
Lower Playoff: Darkwing/Sleeping Dogs (Jennanekogirl Resident, Lovejoyful Resident, Mer7Maids8 Resident, Taya Maruti)
Season 10 – Classic Polo League Season 3 (November 2019)
No title – Season closed without playoffs
Season 11 – Classic Polo League Season 4 (March 2020)
Nightmares from Space (Deadpeace Resident, Hotie Lane, Ralna Payne)
Season 12 – Classic Polo League Season 5 (March 2021)
Upper Playoffs: Requiem (Neceh Zenovka, Penny Pegasi)
Lower Playoffs: Sunset Sirens (Carlalynn2003Laville, JennifurLee Resident, Opheliainnme Resident)
Season 13 – Classic Polo League Season 6 (December 2021)
1st Division: Tearfall Symphony (Penny Pegasi, Wazaaaaaaa85 Resident)
2nd Division: TACKtonics (Discoverygirl45 Resident, Surssin Resident)
Season 14 – Classic Polo League Season 7 (April 2022)
1st Division: Tearfall Symphony (Bobbiboi26 Resident, Luna Sassypants, Penny Pegasi, Pigwitchhouse Resident, Wazaaaaaaa85 Resident
2nd Division: Rubber Noodles (Jessicamorningstar Resident, Magentamolly Resident)